| Name | Year Inducted | Year of Graduation | Sport |
| Thomas W. Greene | 1973 | 1959 | Football, Men's Lacrosse |
| Charles D. Pacunas | 1992 | 1960 | Football, Men's Lacrosse |
| William V. Heaphy III | 2003 | 1961 | Men's Lacrosse |
| John B. Whalen | 2013 | 1962 | Football, Men's Lacrosse |
| James J. Marcellino | 2005 | 1965 | Football, Men's Lacrosse |
| John J. Vrionis | 2010 | 1968 | Football, Men's Lacrosse |
| George A. Paletta, Jr. | 1995 | 1984 | Men's Lacrosse |
