
2009-2010: Named to first team All-New England ... Earned second team All-Patriot League honors ... Named to 2010 Patriot League Academic Honor Roll ... Tied for most amount of rounds played with 20 ... Was the low scorer for Holy Cross four times on the year ... Averaged 76.2 strokes per round ... Shot a 145 at Mulekicker Fall Classic ... Marked a 150 at Southern New Hampshire Invitational ... Scored a 150 at NEGIA Championship ... Notched a 225 at George Washington Inivitational ... Tallied the lowest round of the season (71) at the Mulekicker Classic.
Before Holy Cross: A four-year member and two-time captain of the golf team under head coach Augie Link ... Won the 2008 Connecticut Junior Amateur Championship and advanced to the 2009 Connecticut Amateur Round of 16 ... Finished third at the New England High School Championship ... His Tolland teams twice won the CIAC Division III State Championship ... Honored as team MVP his junior and senior years ... A four-time All-Conference selection, he also received All-State honors on three occasions from the Hartford Courant ... Won an Academic Scholar Award his senior year ... Also played basketball at Tolland.
Personal: Son of Daniel and Darlene McCarthy ... Has two brothers (Brendan and Tom) ... Brother, Tom, is a junior on the Yale golf team ... Has not yet declared a major.
McCarthy's Career Statistics
| Year | Rounds | Strokes | Average | Low Round |
| 2009-2010 | 20 | 1524 | 76.2 | 71 |
| 2010-2011 | 22 | 1,691 | 76.9 | 71 |
| Career | 42 | 3,251 | 76.5 | 71 |









